This writing assignment involves the review and critique of another student’s White Paper.
1. Strengths of the paper
2. weaknesses (Areas that you may consider to improve in future assignments) of the reviewed paper
3. Information learned and wisdom gained from paper.
4. PLEASE SEE ATTACHED: GRADING CRITERIA RUBRIC THAT CAN HELP YOU TO REVIEW/CRITIQUE THIS PAPER.
5. You can add some research or generate some knowledge of what the student is talking about, by agreeing to his research and information—See scholarly articles attached (REMEMBER ALL REFERENCES MUST BE PROFESSIONAL JOURNALS), no books (only our textbook Mastrian & McGonigle, 2017), no conferences or .com stuff.
6. Try your best to sound nice, stating the student weaknesses in a very professional and kind manner. THIS REVIEW/CRITIQUE WILL BE SEND TO THE INSTRUCTOR, BUT ALSO TO THE STUDENT (the writer).
7. Make sure you point out under APA format review (you can put it in your words in the essay): The writer adhered to the APA format for the most part, there are some improvements the writer might consider for future assignments. For instance, APA format requires only the topic, author, and Institution name on the tittle page.
9. SEE ATTACHED STUDENT PAPER for review/critique
10. For this paper you don’t really need to do an introduction. Just the review and a conclusion.
***You might include things like this:
- appropriate references were used throughout the paper
- The purpose of the paper was clearly and concisely stated
-Specifically, the study sought to determine…..
- The abstract reflected the purpose and content of the paper (OR NOT?,? or any suggestion).
- The introduction provide a concise summary of what the paper will address?
- The Background and problems….. well stated? .. problem, why improvement is needed? Well supported by evidence/research?
- the solution well identified, well supported with scholarly resources
- The conclusion? Provided a good Summary of the main points of the paper? No new information should be included…
- The findings were well organized, sectioned, and reported objectively.
- The article used current resources published within the recent 5-7 years
- appropriate references were used throughout the paper
nursing research is crucial, in that it enables nurses to provide the highest quality care to their patients.
- The writer adhered to the APA format for the most part, there are some improvements the writer might consider for future assignments. For instance, when using APA format, there is no need to include name of the class, instructor name and date.
- Overall…
- This was a very in-depth paper… For the most part, it was well written and well organized. Overall, it was a very interesting, significant contribution to the field of ….
